28 April 2026, 13.00 Stockholm
Positivity Diagnostics in Longitudinal Multilevel Causal Inference
Speaker: Huixia Wang, Department of Statistics, Umeå University
Abstract: Practical violations of the positivity assumption are common in longitudinal observational studies and can undermine valid inference. Such violations often arise from complex covariate histories, sparse exposure patterns, and multilevel heterogeneity. To address this problem, we developed a prognostic score–based framework for diagnosing and handling practical positivity violations in such settings. Two implementations were considered: a two-stage approach that defined the support region prior to causal estimation, and an MCMC-based approach that applied hard support restriction within each iteration of the g-formula. For comparison, we also implemented propensity score–based trimming strategies. A simulation study reflecting key features of longitudinal settings showed that the prognostic score–based approaches and the propensity score–based symmetric trimming approach produced broadly similar causal effect estimates under mild to moderate lack of overlap. In contrast, propensity score–based common-support trimming was more sensitive to the treatment assignment mechanism and, in some scenarios, led to more extensive trimming. An application to SHARE data yielded results consistent with the simulation findings.
Venue: MIT.A.346